Theseus vs. Romulus - Debate Activity

Objective: In groups, debate who was the greater leader based on Plutarch’s Parallel Lives. Each side (4 students per team) will argue in favor of either Theseus or Romulus, focusing on different themes.

Team Theseus

• Student 1: Theseus' achievements and reforms in Athens
• Student 2: Theseus' leadership and political impact
• Student 3: Theseus' relationships with family and allies
• Student 4: Theseus' connection to the gods and morality

Team Romulus

• Student 5: Romulus' founding of Rome and military success
• Student 6: Romulus' leadership and governance
• Student 7: Romulus' relationships with family and the Roman people
• Student 8: Romulus' connection to the gods and his legacy

Step 1 (15 minutes): Research your assigned theme using Parallel Lives and other sources.

Step 2 (10 minutes): Discuss with your team and refine arguments.

Step 3 (20 minutes): Debate - each student presents their points (2 minutes each).

Step 4 (10 minutes): Rebuttals and final team arguments.

Step 5 (5 minutes): Class vote - who made the stronger case?